We investigate the effect of two suggested problem properties, basin size contrast and global to local optima contrast, on the performance of different basin identification methods, namely nearest-better clustering, detect-multimodal, and Jarvis-Patrick clustering, individually, or in combinations. Problem instances are generated and validated according to predefined property values and obtained result data is modeled in order to detect similarities that may be interpreted as effects of the stated properties. We also give recommendations concerning usage of basin identification methods in different situations.